new team -- same home

Before Barry Bonds steroided along and entered the upper echelons of home run hitters, I was interested in the fact that (what were then) Major League Baseball's top three players in that department had ended their careers in the same three cities that they started, but playing for different franchises. Those three are:

• Hank Aaron (755 homers, started with the Milwaukee Braves, ended with the Milwaukee Brewers)
• Babe Ruth (714 homers, started with the Boston Red Sox, ended with the Boston Braves)
• Willie Mays (660 homers, started with the New York Giants, ended with the New York Mets)

I mentioned this fact on Twitter, and people liked it. Some also noted a few other big-name players who had done the same. Jimmie Fox, who was, for a long time, second to Babe Ruth in career home runs, did it. Some friends pointed out other -- Yogi Berra, Ron Santo, Marv Throneberry. So I got to wondering just how many players there are. For those who lack patience, I have reproduced the list down below. There are either 235 or 365 players on the list, depending on how you keep score. And to know what I mean by that you'll have to either read further or read my mind (which may be difficult with all the tin foil).

Anyway, before I go on, I want to thank Sean Lanham. I used his downloadable baseball database for this effort.

One challenge is determining what it means for two franchises to be in the same city. One case in point is the case of Brooklyn. Do I consider that part of New York City? It is part of New York. Of course, before 1898 it was a separate city. So one obvious solution is to literally go by city. But that would require me to distiguish pre-1898 Brooklyn (which remains Brooklyn) from post-1897 Brooklyn (which is New York). And, if I'm going down that road, do I have to check where every team played its home games? From the world of football, I know that neither the Jets nor Giants play in new York (despite their names). I'll bet there are cases in MLB history where teams played their home games outside of the cities for which they were named. But it does seem silly, if a team is called "New York" but plays just across the river in New Jersey, to consider them not to be a New York team. Certainly, it would ruin the spirit of the enterprise.

In the end, I decided on two approaches that seem credible.

• Method 1: Categorize teams according to how they are named. Under this convention, the Brooklyn Dodgers and the New York Mets are not considered to be from the same location. Similarly, the Angels had three locations (Los Angeles, California and Anaheim), despite always being from the Los Angeles metropolitan area. A player who started his career with the Los Angeles Dodgers and ended with the California Angels (or Anaheim Angels) would not be counted. By this method, there were 235 players on the list.
• Method 2: Categorize teams by metropolitan area they are from. Using this methodology, a player who began his career with the Los Angeles Dodgers and ended with the Angels would be counted -- regardless of which incarnation of the Angels he ended with. One drawback of this method is that it requires a bit of judgement to decide if two locations are part of the same metropolitan area. In the end, I had 46 metropolitan areas. I list them all here, but I will show the five which included more than one "location" (as indicated by team name). By this method there were 365 players on the list.
• Los Angeles -- includes Anaheim, California and Los Angeles
• Miami -- includes Florida and Miami
• Minneapolis / St. Paul -- includes Minnesota and St. Paul
• New York -- includes Brooklyn, Elizabeth, New York and Newark
• San Francisco / Oakland -- includes Oakland and San Francisco

If you disagree with my choices, let me know in the comments. Maybe I'll redo the work if I am convinced of my wrongness.

With two credible methodologies, I couldn't decide which to use. So I compromised and did this both ways. It wasn't really much extra work, so what the heck. Rather than show two separate lists, where one is actually a subset of the other, I decided to combine and present one list. The players are listed in alphabetical order. The first column shows numbering for players based on methodology 1 (with "N/A" indicating the player is not on the list). The second column shows numbering for players based on methodology 2.

But before the list, I have a few comments and observations.

I found five players on the list who only played during one season. Yes. Five players moved from one team to another (in the same metropolitan area -- four within the same city) during their debut season, and never played in another season. Those players are:

• John Burns who played in 1884 for the Baltimore Orioles and Baltimore Monumentals;
• Robert Foster who played in 1884 for the Philadelphia Keystones and Philadelphia Athletics;
• Bob Murphy who played in 1890 for the New York Giants and Brooklyn Gladiators;
• Henry Oxley who played in 1884 for the New York Gothams and New York Metropolitans;
• Ed Yewell who played in 1884 for two franchises called the Washington Nationals (in different leagues).

The 1884 Chicago/Pittsburgh franchise in the Union Association presented a special challenge, since the team moved during the year. Fortunately, I only found one player (Will Foley) for whom this was a potential issue. Foley began his career in 1875 with the Chicago White Stockings, and ended it in 1884 with Chicago/Pittsburgh. But a little research revealed that he played his last game before the team moved to Pitssburgh. So he's on the list.

These statistics run through 2019 (duh). They assume that all players who were active in 2019 ended their careers then. Some who are on the list may eventually be off the list when all is said and done.

Finally, I have to note a bit of bad form. I should have done this in such a way that I could share the final file on Dropbox or something similar. I didn't. In my process, I repeatedly erased records or fields from the data tables that I didn't need. I intend to redo the analysis in a way that preserves the data. Both to share it (for auditability) and so I can do other things with it. If that does happen, there will be follow up posts.

I am open to suggestions for other things to do with these data.

And now the data...

Num (Loc)	Num (Metro)	Name	First Team	Last Team
1	1	Hank Aaron	1954 Milwaukee Braves	1976 Milwaukee Brewers
N/A	2	Jeremy Accardo	2005 San Francisco Giants	2012 Oakland Athletics
2	3	Johnny Allen	1932 New York Yankees	1944 New York Giants
N/A	4	Orlando Alvarez	1973 Los Angeles Dodgers	1976 California Angels
N/A	5	Garret Anderson	1994 California Angels	2010 Los Angeles Dodgers
3	6	Joe Ardner	1884 Cleveland Blues	1890 Cleveland Spiders
N/A	7	Bob Aspromonte	1956 Brooklyn Dodgers	1971 New York Mets
N/A	8	Charlie Babb	1903 New York Giants	1905 Brooklyn Superbas
4	9	Ed Bagley	1884 New York Gothams	1885 New York Metropolitans
5	10	Bill Bailey	1907 St. Louis Browns	1922 St. Louis Cardinals
N/A	11	Tom Baker	1935 Brooklyn Dodgers	1938 New York Giants
6	12	Frank Barberich	1907 Boston Doves	1910 Boston Red Sox
N/A	13	Larry Barnes	2001 Anaheim Angels	2003 Los Angeles Dodgers
7	14	Ross Barnes	1871 Boston Red Stockings	1881 Boston Red Caps
8	15	Dick Barrett	1933 Philadelphia Athletics	1945 Philadelphia Phillies
N/A	16	Bill Bathe	1986 Oakland Athletics	1990 San Francisco Giants
9	17	Stan Baumgartner	1914 Philadelphia Phillies	1926 Philadelphia Athletics
10	18	Buck Becannon	1884 New York Metropolitans	1887 New York Giants
11	19	Joe Beggs	1938 New York Yankees	1948 New York Giants
N/A	20	Hank Behrman	1946 Brooklyn Dodgers	1949 New York Giants
N/A	21	Tim Belcher	1987 Los Angeles Dodgers	2000 Anaheim Angels
12	22	Yogi Berra	1946 New York Yankees	1965 New York Mets
N/A	23	Ray Berres	1934 Brooklyn Dodgers	1945 New York Giants
N/A	24	Harry Billiard	1908 New York Highlanders	1915 Newark Pepper
13	25	Hi Bithorn	1942 Chicago Cubs	1947 Chicago White Sox
14	26	Joe Blong	1875 St. Louis Red Stockings	1877 St. Louis Brown Stockings
N/A	27	Vida Blue	1969 Oakland Athletics	1986 San Francisco Giants
15	28	Zeke Bonura	1934 Chicago White Sox	1940 Chicago Cubs
N/A	29	Ike Boone	1922 New York Giants	1932 Brooklyn Dodgers
16	30	Jim Bottomley	1922 St. Louis Cardinals	1937 St. Louis Browns
17	31	Sumner Bowman	1890 Philadelphia Phillies	1891 Philadelphia Athletics
N/A	32	Bill Boyd	1872 New York Mutuals	1875 Brooklyn Atlantics
18	33	Harry Brecheen	1940 St. Louis Cardinals	1953 St. Louis Browns
19	34	Don Brennan	1933 New York Yankees	1937 New York Giants
20	35	Jim Brosnan	1954 Chicago Cubs	1963 Chicago White Sox
21	36	Lew Brown	1876 Boston Red Caps	1884 Boston Reds
22	37	Fritz Buelow	1899 St. Louis Perfectos	1907 St. Louis Browns
23	38	Jack Burdock	1872 Brooklyn Atlantics	1891 Brooklyn Grooms
24	39	Smoky Burgess	1949 Chicago Cubs	1967 Chicago White Sox
25	40	John Burns	1884 Baltimore Orioles	1884 Baltimore Monumentals
N/A	41	Buster Burrell	1891 New York Giants	1897 Brooklyn Bridegrooms
26	42	Doc Bushong	1875 Brooklyn Atlantics	1890 Brooklyn Bridegrooms
27	43	Nick Buss	2013 Los Angeles Dodgers	2016 Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim
N/A	44	Leon Cadore	1915 Brooklyn Robins	1924 New York Giants
28	45	Howie Camnitz	1904 Pittsburgh Pirates	1915 Pittsburgh Rebels
29	46	Robinson Cano	2005 New York Yankees	2019 New York Mets
N/A	47	Ben Cantwell	1927 New York Giants	1937 Brooklyn Dodgers
30	48	John Cassidy	1875 Brooklyn Atlantics	1885 Brooklyn Grays
31	49	Welington Castillo	2010 Chicago Cubs	2019 Chicago White Sox
32	50	Phil Cavarretta	1934 Chicago Cubs	1955 Chicago White Sox
33	51	Chet Chadbourne	1906 Boston Americans	1918 Boston Braves
34	52	Hal Chase	1905 New York Highlanders	1919 New York Giants
N/A	53	Doug Clark	2005 San Francisco Giants	2006 Oakland Athletics
35	54	Clem Clemens	1914 Chicago Chi-Feds	1916 Chicago Cubs
36	55	Verne Clemons	1916 St. Louis Browns	1924 St. Louis Cardinals
37	56	Jack Coffey	1909 Boston Doves	1918 Boston Red Sox
38	57	Gene Conley	1952 Boston Braves	1963 Boston Red Sox
N/A	58	Peter Connell	1886 New York Metropolitans	1890 Brooklyn Gladiators
39	59	William Coon	1875 Philadelphia Athletics	1876 Philadelphia Athletics
40	60	Jimmy Cooney	1917 Boston Red Sox	1928 Boston Braves
41	61	Bill Cox	1936 St. Louis Cardinals	1940 St. Louis Browns
N/A	62	Fred Crane	1873 Elizabeth Resolutes	1875 Brooklyn Atlantics
N/A	63	John D'Acquisto	1973 San Francisco Giants	1982 Oakland Athletics
42	64	Bill Daley	1889 Boston Beaneaters	1891 Boston Reds
43	65	Abner Dalrymple	1878 Milwaukee Grays	1891 Milwaukee Brewers
44	66	Tom Daly	1913 Chicago White Sox	1921 Chicago Cubs
45	67	Ike Davis	2010 New York Mets	2016 New York Yankees
N/A	68	Willie Davis	1960 Los Angeles Dodgers	1979 California Angels
46	69	Dizzy Dean	1930 St. Louis Cardinals	1947 St. Louis Browns
47	70	Paul Dean	1934 St. Louis Cardinals	1943 St. Louis Browns
48	71	Mike Diaz	1983 Chicago Cubs	1988 Chicago White Sox
49	72	Tommy Dowd	1891 Boston Reds	1901 Boston Americans
N/A	73	Kelly Downs	1986 San Francisco Giants	1993 Oakland Athletics
50	74	Moe Drabowsky	1956 Chicago Cubs	1972 Chicago White Sox
N/A	75	Jack Dunn	1897 Brooklyn Bridegrooms	1904 New York Giants
N/A	76	Bull Durham	1904 Brooklyn Superbas	1909 New York Giants
N/A	77	Leo Durocher	1925 New York Yankees	1945 Brooklyn Dodgers
51	78	Lee Elia	1966 Chicago White Sox	1968 Chicago Cubs
N/A	79	Gil English	1931 New York Giants	1944 Brooklyn Dodgers
52	80	Nick Etten	1938 Philadelphia Athletics	1947 Philadelphia Phillies
53	81	Roy Evans	1897 St. Louis Browns	1903 St. Louis Browns
N/A	82	Ron Fairly	1958 Los Angeles Dodgers	1978 California Angels
54	83	Sid Farrar	1883 Philadelphia Quakers	1890 Philadelphia Athletics
N/A	84	John Farrow	1873 Elizabeth Resolutes	1884 Brooklyn Atlantics
N/A	85	Jim Faulkner	1927 New York Giants	1930 Brooklyn Robins
N/A	86	Alex Ferguson	1918 New York Yankees	1929 Brooklyn Robins
N/A	87	Joe Ferguson	1970 Los Angeles Dodgers	1983 California Angels
N/A	88	Chico Fernandez	1956 Brooklyn Dodgers	1963 New York Mets
N/A	89	Chick Fewster	1917 New York Yankees	1927 Brooklyn Robins
N/A	90	Chone Figgins	2002 Anaheim Angels	2014 Los Angeles Dodgers
55	91	Dana Fillingim	1915 Philadelphia Athletics	1925 Philadelphia Phillies
N/A	92	Jack Fimple	1983 Los Angeles Dodgers	1987 California Angels
56	93	Lou Finney	1931 Philadelphia Athletics	1947 Philadelphia Phillies
57	94	Wes Fisler	1871 Philadelphia Athletics	1876 Philadelphia Athletics
N/A	95	Freddie Fitzsimmons	1925 New York Giants	1943 Brooklyn Dodgers
N/A	96	Frank Fleet	1871 New York Mutuals	1875 Brooklyn Atlantics
58	97	Jim Fogarty	1884 Philadelphia Quakers	1890 Philadelphia Athletics
59	98	Will Foley	1875 Chicago White Stockings	1884 Chicago/Pittsburgh (Union League)
60	99	Davy Force	1871 Washington Olympics	1886 Washington Nationals
61	100	Robert Foster	1884 Philadelphia Keystones	1884 Philadelphia Athletics
N/A	101	Keith Foulke	1997 San Francisco Giants	2008 Oakland Athletics
62	102	Jimmie Foxx	1925 Philadelphia Athletics	1945 Philadelphia Phillies
63	103	Ken Frailing	1972 Chicago White Sox	1976 Chicago Cubs
N/A	104	Lonny Frey	1933 Brooklyn Dodgers	1948 New York Giants
N/A	105	Tito Fuentes	1965 San Francisco Giants	1978 Oakland Athletics
64	106	Kosuke Fukudome	2008 Chicago Cubs	2012 Chicago White Sox
N/A	107	Joe Gallagher	1939 New York Yankees	1940 Brooklyn Dodgers
65	108	Pud Galvin	1875 St. Louis Brown Stockings	1892 St. Louis Browns
66	109	Oscar Gamble	1969 Chicago Cubs	1985 Chicago White Sox
67	110	Debs Garms	1932 St. Louis Browns	1945 St. Louis Cardinals
N/A	111	Phil Garner	1973 Oakland Athletics	1988 San Francisco Giants
N/A	112	Dan Giese	2007 San Francisco Giants	2009 Oakland Athletics
N/A	113	Jose Gonzalez	1985 Los Angeles Dodgers	1992 California Angels
68	114	Dwight Gooden	1984 New York Mets	2000 New York Yankees
69	115	Johnny Gray	1954 Philadelphia Athletics	1958 Philadelphia Phillies
70	116	Danny Green	1898 Chicago Orphans	1905 Chicago White Sox
N/A	117	Kent Greenfield	1924 New York Giants	1929 Brooklyn Robins
N/A	118	Hal Gregg	1943 Brooklyn Dodgers	1952 New York Giants
71	119	Bob Habenicht	1951 St. Louis Cardinals	1953 St. Louis Browns
72	120	Warren Hacker	1948 Chicago Cubs	1961 Chicago White Sox
73	121	Walter Hackett	1884 Boston Reds	1885 Boston Beaneaters
74	122	George Haddock	1888 Washington Nationals	1894 Washington Senators
75	123	Ralph Hamner	1946 Chicago White Sox	1949 Chicago Cubs
N/A	124	Joe Harris	1914 New York Yankees	1928 Brooklyn Robins
N/A	125	Buddy Hassett	1936 Brooklyn Dodgers	1942 New York Yankees
76	126	John Hatfield	1871 New York Mutuals	1876 New York Mutuals
77	127	Bill Heath	1965 Chicago White Sox	1969 Chicago Cubs
N/A	128	Dave Heaverlo	1975 San Francisco Giants	1981 Oakland Athletics
78	129	Sean Henn	2005 New York Yankees	2013 New York Mets
N/A	130	Gil Heredia	1991 San Francisco Giants	2001 Oakland Athletics
79	131	Orlando Hernandez	1998 New York Yankees	2007 New York Mets
80	132	Rudy Hernandez	1960 Washington Senators	1961 Washington Senators
81	133	Lefty Herring	1899 Washington Senators	1904 Washington Senators
82	134	Frank Hiller	1946 New York Yankees	1953 New York Giants
83	135	Charlie Hilsey	1883 Philadelphia Quakers	1884 Philadelphia Athletics
84	136	Paul Hines	1872 Washington Nationals	1891 Washington Statesmen
N/A	137	Gil Hodges	1943 Brooklyn Dodgers	1963 New York Mets
85	138	Charlie Hodnett	1883 St. Louis Browns	1884 St. Louis Maroons
86	139	Holly Hollingshead	1872 Washington Nationals	1875 Washington Nationals
87	140	Rogers Hornsby	1915 St. Louis Cardinals	1937 St. Louis Browns
88	141	Bob Howry	1998 Chicago White Sox	2010 Chicago Cubs
N/A	142	Waite Hoyt	1918 New York Giants	1938 Brooklyn Dodgers
N/A	143	Bill Hubbell	1919 New York Giants	1925 Brooklyn Robins
N/A	144	Johnny Hudson	1936 Brooklyn Dodgers	1945 New York Giants
N/A	145	Tim Hudson	1999 Oakland Athletics	2015 San Francisco Giants
N/A	146	John Hummel	1905 Brooklyn Superbas	1918 New York Yankees
89	147	Pat Hynes	1903 St. Louis Cardinals	1904 St. Louis Browns
90	148	Ryota Igarashi	2010 New York Mets	2012 New York Yankees
91	149	Frank Isbell	1898 Chicago Orphans	1909 Chicago White Sox
92	150	Darrin Jackson	1985 Chicago Cubs	1999 Chicago White Sox
N/A	151	Merwin Jacobson	1915 New York Giants	1927 Brooklyn Robins
N/A	152	Jay Johnstone	1966 California Angels	1985 Los Angeles Dodgers
93	153	Levin Jones	1873 Baltimore Marylands	1874 Baltimore Canaries
N/A	154	Spider Jorgensen	1947 Brooklyn Dodgers	1951 New York Giants
N/A	155	Bill Joyce	1890 Brooklyn Ward's Wonders	1898 New York Giants
N/A	156	Frank Kane	1915 Brooklyn Tip-Tops	1919 New York Yankees
94	157	Joe Kappel	1884 Philadelphia Quakers	1890 Philadelphia Athletics
95	158	Matt Karchner	1995 Chicago White Sox	2000 Chicago Cubs
96	159	Andy Karl	1943 Boston Red Sox	1947 Boston Braves
97	160	Benny Kauff	1912 New York Highlanders	1920 New York Giants
98	161	George Keefe	1886 Washington Nationals	1891 Washington Statesmen
99	162	Bill Kelly	1920 Philadelphia Athletics	1928 Philadelphia Phillies
100	163	Charlie Kelly	1883 Philadelphia Quakers	1886 Philadelphia Athletics
N/A	164	High Pockets Kelly	1915 New York Giants	1932 Brooklyn Dodgers
N/A	165	Ed Kennedy	1883 New York Metropolitans	1886 Brooklyn Grays
101	166	Don Kessinger	1964 Chicago Cubs	1979 Chicago White Sox
102	167	Bill Kienzle	1882 Philadelphia Athletics	1884 Philadelphia Keystones
N/A	168	Pete Kilduff	1917 New York Giants	1921 Brooklyn Robins
N/A	169	Brian Kingman	1979 Oakland Athletics	1983 San Francisco Giants
N/A	170	Dave Kingman	1971 San Francisco Giants	1986 Oakland Athletics
N/A	171	Fred Kipp	1957 Brooklyn Dodgers	1960 New York Yankees
103	172	John Kirby	1884 Kansas City Cowboys	1888 Kansas City Cowboys
104	173	Brandon Knight	2001 New York Yankees	2008 New York Mets
N/A	174	Len Koenecke	1932 New York Giants	1935 Brooklyn Dodgers
105	175	Mark Koenig	1925 New York Yankees	1936 New York Giants
106	176	Ken Kravec	1975 Chicago White Sox	1982 Chicago Cubs
107	177	Charlie Krehmeyer	1884 St. Louis Browns	1885 St. Louis Maroons
108	178	Rube Kroh	1906 Boston Americans	1912 Boston Braves
N/A	179	Clem Labine	1950 Brooklyn Dodgers	1962 New York Mets
N/A	180	Bob Lacey	1977 Oakland Athletics	1984 San Francisco Giants
109	181	Nap Lajoie	1896 Philadelphia Phillies	1916 Philadelphia Athletics
N/A	182	Ken Landreaux	1977 California Angels	1987 Los Angeles Dodgers
110	183	Max Lanier	1938 St. Louis Cardinals	1953 St. Louis Browns
N/A	184	Frank LaPorte	1905 New York Highlanders	1915 Newark Pepper
N/A	185	Tacks Latimer	1898 New York Giants	1902 Brooklyn Superbas
111	186	Doc Lavan	1913 St. Louis Browns	1924 St. Louis Cardinals
N/A	187	Gary Lavelle	1974 San Francisco Giants	1987 Oakland Athletics
112	188	Tony Lazzeri	1926 New York Yankees	1939 New York Giants
113	189	Bevo LeBourveau	1919 Philadelphia Phillies	1929 Philadelphia Athletics
114	190	Ricky Ledee	1998 New York Yankees	2007 New York Mets
115	191	Lou Legett	1929 Boston Braves	1935 Boston Red Sox
N/A	192	Johnnie LeMaster	1975 San Francisco Giants	1987 Oakland Athletics
116	193	Dave Lemonds	1969 Chicago Cubs	1972 Chicago White Sox
117	194	Charlie Levis	1884 Baltimore Monumentals	1885 Baltimore Orioles
118	195	Ted Lewis	1896 Boston Beaneaters	1901 Boston Americans
119	196	Cory Lidle	1997 New York Mets	2006 New York Yankees
N/A	197	Freddie Lindstrom	1924 New York Giants	1936 Brooklyn Dodgers
120	198	Phil Linz	1962 New York Yankees	1968 New York Mets
121	199	Bob Locker	1965 Chicago White Sox	1975 Chicago Cubs
122	200	Tom Loftus	1877 St. Louis Brown Stockings	1883 St. Louis Browns
N/A	201	Ernie Lombardi	1931 Brooklyn Robins	1947 New York Giants
123	202	Phil Lombardi	1986 New York Yankees	1989 New York Mets
124	203	Terrence Long	1999 New York Mets	2006 New York Yankees
125	204	Turk Lown	1951 Chicago Cubs	1962 Chicago White Sox
N/A	205	Ray Lucas	1929 New York Giants	1934 Brooklyn Dodgers
126	206	Tony Lyons	1920 St. Louis Cardinals	1924 St. Louis Browns
127	207	Danny MacFayden	1926 Boston Red Sox	1943 Boston Braves
128	208	Hector Maestri	1960 Washington Senators	1961 Washington Senators
129	209	Fergy Malone	1871 Philadelphia Athletics	1884 Philadelphia Keystones
130	210	Marty Marion	1940 St. Louis Cardinals	1953 St. Louis Browns
N/A	211	Mike Marshall	1981 Los Angeles Dodgers	1991 California Angels
131	212	Al Martin	1872 Brooklyn Eckfords	1875 Brooklyn Atlantics
132	213	J. C. Martin	1959 Chicago White Sox	1972 Chicago Cubs
133	214	Randy Martz	1980 Chicago Cubs	1983 Chicago White Sox
134	215	Charlie Mason	1875 Philadelphia Centennials	1883 Philadelphia Athletics
N/A	216	Mike Mattimore	1887 New York Giants	1890 Brooklyn Gladiators
135	217	Willie Mays	1951 New York Giants	1973 New York Mets
N/A	218	Vin Mazzaro	2009 Oakland Athletics	2016 San Francisco Giants
136	219	Jim McAnany	1958 Chicago White Sox	1962 Chicago Cubs
N/A	220	Johnny McCarthy	1934 Brooklyn Dodgers	1948 New York Giants
137	221	Tom McGuire	1914 Chicago Chi-Feds	1919 Chicago White Sox
138	222	Stuffy McInnis	1909 Philadelphia Athletics	1927 Philadelphia Phillies
139	223	Polly McLarry	1912 Chicago White Sox	1915 Chicago Cubs
N/A	224	Tommy McMillan	1908 Brooklyn Superbas	1912 New York Highlanders
140	225	John McPherson	1901 Philadelphia Athletics	1904 Philadelphia Phillies
141	226	Trick McSorley	1875 St. Louis Red Stockings	1886 St. Louis Browns
142	227	Fred Merkle	1907 New York Giants	1926 New York Yankees
N/A	228	Andy Messersmith	1968 California Angels	1979 Los Angeles Dodgers
143	229	Levi Meyerle	1871 Philadelphia Athletics	1884 Philadelphia Keystones
144	230	George Miller	1877 Cincinnati Reds	1884 Cincinnati Red Stockings
145	231	Fred Mitchell	1901 Boston Americans	1913 Boston Braves
N/A	232	Johnny Mitchell	1921 New York Yankees	1925 Brooklyn Robins
146	233	George Moriarty	1903 Chicago Cubs	1916 Chicago White Sox
147	234	John Morrill	1876 Boston Red Caps	1890 Boston Reds
148	235	Heinie Mueller	1920 St. Louis Cardinals	1935 St. Louis Browns
N/A	236	Van Mungo	1931 Brooklyn Robins	1945 New York Giants
N/A	237	Bob Murphy	1890 New York Giants	1890 Brooklyn Gladiators
N/A	238	Danny Murphy	1900 New York Giants	1915 Brooklyn Tip-Tops
149	239	Danny Murphy	1960 Chicago Cubs	1970 Chicago White Sox
150	240	Skeeter Newsome	1935 Philadelphia Athletics	1947 Philadelphia Phillies
151	241	Bill Nicholson	1936 Philadelphia Athletics	1953 Philadelphia Phillies
152	242	Wayne Nordhagen	1976 Chicago White Sox	1983 Chicago Cubs
N/A	243	Darby O'Brien	1887 New York Metropolitans	1892 Brooklyn Grooms
153	244	Lefty O'Doul	1919 New York Yankees	1934 New York Giants
154	245	Will Ohman	2000 Chicago Cubs	2012 Chicago White Sox
N/A	246	Dave Orr	1883 New York Metropolitans	1890 Brooklyn Ward's Wonders
N/A	247	Phil Ortega	1960 Los Angeles Dodgers	1969 California Angels
155	248	Jose Ortiz	1969 Chicago White Sox	1971 Chicago Cubs
156	249	Johnny Ostrowski	1943 Chicago Cubs	1950 Chicago White Sox
157	250	Henry Oxley	1884 New York Gothams	1884 New York Metropolitans
158	251	Juan Padilla	2004 New York Yankees	2005 New York Mets
159	252	Reggie Patterson	1981 Chicago White Sox	1985 Chicago Cubs
N/A	253	Tom Patterson	1871 New York Mutuals	1875 Brooklyn Atlantics
160	254	Charlie Pechous	1915 Chicago Whales	1917 Chicago Cubs
161	255	Ray Pepper	1932 St. Louis Cardinals	1936 St. Louis Browns
N/A	256	Ron Perranoski	1961 Los Angeles Dodgers	1973 California Angels
N/A	257	Joe Pignatano	1957 Brooklyn Dodgers	1962 New York Mets
N/A	258	Norman Plitt	1918 Brooklyn Robins	1927 New York Giants
162	259	Jay Porter	1952 St. Louis Browns	1959 St. Louis Cardinals
163	260	Jim Qualls	1969 Chicago Cubs	1972 Chicago White Sox
164	261	Tom Quinn	1886 Pittsburg Alleghenys	1890 Pittsburgh Burghers
165	262	Jose Quintana	2012 Chicago White Sox	2019 Chicago Cubs
166	263	John Radcliff	1871 Philadelphia Athletics	1875 Philadelphia Centennials
167	264	Pedro Ramos	1955 Washington Senators	1970 Washington Senators
N/A	265	Doug Rau	1972 Los Angeles Dodgers	1981 California Angels
168	266	Bob Reach	1872 Washington Olympics	1873 Washington Blue Legs
169	267	Jeff Reardon	1979 New York Mets	1994 New York Yankees
N/A	268	Bill Reidy	1896 New York Giants	1904 Brooklyn Superbas
170	269	John Reilly	1880 Cincinnati Reds	1891 Cincinnati Reds
171	270	Jack Remsen	1872 Brooklyn Atlantics	1884 Brooklyn Atlantics
172	271	Hal Reniff	1961 New York Yankees	1967 New York Mets
173	272	Carl Reynolds	1927 Chicago White Sox	1939 Chicago Cubs
174	273	Woody Rich	1939 Boston Red Sox	1944 Boston Braves
175	274	Ken Richardson	1942 Philadelphia Athletics	1946 Philadelphia Phillies
176	275	Marv Rickert	1942 Chicago Cubs	1950 Chicago White Sox
177	276	Joe Riggert	1911 Boston Red Sox	1919 Boston Braves
N/A	277	Adam Riggs	1997 Los Angeles Dodgers	2004 Anaheim Angels
178	278	Royce Ring	2005 New York Mets	2010 New York Yankees
N/A	279	Rick Rodriguez	1986 Oakland Athletics	1990 San Francisco Giants
179	280	Red Rollings	1927 Boston Red Sox	1930 Boston Braves
N/A	281	Goody Rosen	1937 Brooklyn Dodgers	1946 New York Giants
180	282	Jack Rowe	1879 Buffalo Bisons	1890 Buffalo Bisons
181	283	Bob Rush	1948 Chicago Cubs	1960 Chicago White Sox
182	284	Babe Ruth	1914 Boston Red Sox	1935 Boston Braves
N/A	285	Rosy Ryan	1919 New York Giants	1933 Brooklyn Dodgers
183	286	Ken Sanders	1964 Kansas City Athletics	1976 Kansas City Royals
184	287	Ron Santo	1960 Chicago Cubs	1974 Chicago White Sox
185	288	Harry Schafer	1871 Boston Red Stockings	1878 Boston Red Caps
186	289	Johnny Schaive	1958 Washington Senators	1963 Washington Senators
N/A	290	Al Scheer	1913 Brooklyn Superbas	1915 Newark Pepper
187	291	Hank Schreiber	1914 Chicago White Sox	1926 Chicago Cubs
N/A	292	Paul Schreiber	1922 Brooklyn Robins	1945 New York Yankees
N/A	293	Dave Sells	1972 California Angels	1975 Los Angeles Dodgers
188	294	George Seward	1875 St. Louis Brown Stockings	1882 St. Louis Brown Stockings
189	295	Bobby Shantz	1949 Philadelphia Athletics	1964 Philadelphia Phillies
N/A	296	Tommy Sheehan	1900 New York Giants	1908 Brooklyn Superbas
N/A	297	Larry Sherry	1958 Los Angeles Dodgers	1968 California Angels
N/A	298	Craig Shipley	1986 Los Angeles Dodgers	1998 Anaheim Angels
190	299	Ernie Shore	1912 New York Giants	1920 New York Yankees
191	300	Burt Shotton	1909 St. Louis Browns	1923 St. Louis Cardinals
192	301	Clyde Shoun	1935 Chicago Cubs	1949 Chicago White Sox
193	302	Frank Shugart	1890 Chicago Pirates	1901 Chicago White Sox
194	303	Bill Smiley	1874 Baltimore Canaries	1882 Baltimore Orioles
N/A	304	Aleck Smith	1897 Brooklyn Bridegrooms	1906 New York Giants
N/A	305	George Smith	1916 New York Giants	1923 Brooklyn Robins
195	306	Phenomenal Smith	1884 Philadelphia Athletics	1891 Philadelphia Phillies
196	307	Pop Snyder	1873 Washington Blue Legs	1891 Washington Statesmen
197	308	Allan Sothoron	1914 St. Louis Browns	1926 St. Louis Cardinals
198	309	Geovany Soto	2005 Chicago Cubs	2017 Chicago White Sox
199	310	Shane Spencer	1998 New York Yankees	2004 New York Mets
200	311	Stan Sperry	1936 Philadelphia Phillies	1938 Philadelphia Athletics
201	312	Chick Stahl	1897 Boston Beaneaters	1906 Boston Americans
202	313	Roy Staiger	1975 New York Mets	1979 New York Yankees
N/A	314	Jigger Statz	1919 New York Giants	1928 Brooklyn Robins
203	315	Bill Stearns	1871 Washington Olympics	1875 Washington Nationals
N/A	316	Milt Stock	1913 New York Giants	1926 Brooklyn Robins
204	317	Len Stockwell	1879 Cleveland Blues	1890 Cleveland Spiders
205	318	Darryl Strawberry	1983 New York Mets	1999 New York Yankees
206	319	Tom Sturdivant	1955 New York Yankees	1964 New York Mets
N/A	320	Eric Surkamp	2011 San Francisco Giants	2016 Oakland Athletics
N/A	321	Marty Swandell	1872 Brooklyn Eckfords	1873 Elizabeth Resolutes
207	322	Ryan Sweeney	2006 Chicago White Sox	2014 Chicago Cubs
208	323	Ron Swoboda	1965 New York Mets	1973 New York Yankees
N/A	324	Vito Tamulis	1934 New York Yankees	1941 Brooklyn Dodgers
209	325	Ralph Terry	1956 New York Yankees	1967 New York Mets
210	326	Zeb Terry	1916 Chicago White Sox	1922 Chicago Cubs
N/A	327	Henry Thielman	1902 New York Giants	1903 Brooklyn Superbas
211	328	Sam Thompson	1885 Detroit Wolverines	1906 Detroit Tigers
N/A	329	Hank Thormahlen	1917 New York Yankees	1925 Brooklyn Robins
212	330	Marv Throneberry	1955 New York Yankees	1963 New York Mets
213	331	Steve Toole	1886 Brooklyn Grays	1890 Brooklyn Gladiators
N/A	332	Jeff Torborg	1964 Los Angeles Dodgers	1973 California Angels
214	333	Bill Trotter	1937 St. Louis Browns	1944 St. Louis Cardinals
N/A	334	Ty Tyson	1926 New York Giants	1928 Brooklyn Robins
215	335	Elmer Valo	1940 Philadelphia Athletics	1961 Philadelphia Phillies
N/A	336	Pat Venditte	2015 Oakland Athletics	2019 San Francisco Giants
216	337	Bill Vinton	1884 Philadelphia Quakers	1885 Philadelphia Athletics
217	338	Hal Wagner	1937 Philadelphia Athletics	1949 Philadelphia Phillies
N/A	339	Joe Wall	1901 New York Giants	1902 Brooklyn Superbas
218	340	Josh Wall	2012 Los Angeles Dodgers	2014 Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim
219	341	Murray Wall	1950 Boston Braves	1959 Boston Red Sox
N/A	342	Eric Weaver	1998 Los Angeles Dodgers	2000 Anaheim Angels
220	343	Sam Weaver	1875 Philadelphia Whites	1886 Philadelphia Athletics
221	344	Billy Werber	1930 New York Yankees	1942 New York Giants
N/A	345	Johnny Werhas	1964 Los Angeles Dodgers	1967 California Angels
N/A	346	Billy West	1874 Brooklyn Atlantics	1876 New York Mutuals
222	347	Warren White	1871 Washington Olympics	1884 Washington Nationals
223	348	Wally Whitehurst	1989 New York Mets	1996 New York Yankees
N/A	349	Kemp Wicker	1936 New York Yankees	1941 Brooklyn Dodgers
224	350	Dave Wickersham	1960 Kansas City Athletics	1969 Kansas City Royals
225	351	Wild Bill Widner	1887 Cincinnati Red Stockings	1891 Cincinnati Kelly's Killers
226	352	Joe Wilhoit	1916 Boston Braves	1919 Boston Red Sox
227	353	Gerald Williams	1992 New York Yankees	2005 New York Mets
228	354	Joe Willis	1911 St. Louis Browns	1913 St. Louis Cardinals
N/A	355	Hooks Wiltse	1904 New York Giants	1915 Brooklyn Tip-Tops
229	356	Kettle Wirts	1921 Chicago Cubs	1924 Chicago White Sox
230	357	Mickey Witek	1940 New York Giants	1949 New York Yankees
N/A	358	Rynie Wolters	1871 New York Mutuals	1873 Elizabeth Resolutes
231	359	Harry Wright	1871 Boston Red Stockings	1877 Boston Red Caps
N/A	360	Keiichi Yabu	2005 Oakland Athletics	2008 San Francisco Giants
232	361	Ed Yewell	1884 Washington Nationals	1884 Washington Nationals
233	362	Tom Zachary	1918 Philadelphia Athletics	1936 Philadelphia Phillies
N/A	363	Geoff Zahn	1973 Los Angeles Dodgers	1985 California Angels
234	364	Rollie Zeider	1910 Chicago White Sox	1918 Chicago Cubs
235	365	Dutch Zwilling	1910 Chicago White Sox	1916 Chicago Cubs